Whether we proudly follow celebrity couples or not, we’re all well aware of Justin Bieber and Selena Gomez’s on-again-off-again, iconic romantic history. They were a teen dream romance that a lot of people, including them, struggled to leave behind.
So since news broke that Justin Bieber is reportedly engaged to model Hailey Baldwin, it’s left a sour taste in a lot of our mouths.
how is justin bieber gonna marry someone that isn’t selena gomez? what a scam
— nitch (@KaitlinNitsche) July 8, 2018
Hailey Baldwin is the only other celebrity besides Selena Gomez that Bieber famously has a long romantic history with, but their narrative is currently of little interest to anyone.
All we want to talk about is Selena Gomez. Is Selena Gomez OK? How Does Selena Gomez feel? How STUPID is Justin Bieber for not ending up with Selena Gomez!? On Twitter #SelenaIsFreeParty is trending higher than the actual engagement news. Clearly the world has picked a side.
Omg Selena was trending higher than Hailey Baldwin and now #SelenaIsFreeParty is also Trending higher than Hailey. Her name has more tweets than the person who got engaged, all while she is in hiding on a boat while minding her business. Ugh, HER MIND!??#SelenaIsFreeParty pic.twitter.com/mwfmuGVSyu
— Fizzy (@backtofizzy) July 8, 2018
That’s because when it comes to a love triangle we prefer to rally behind the ‘victim’. The one who is left behind becomes our new single icon and their empowerment is our coping mechanism for the trials and tribulations of dating.
In this situation, Bieber and Baldwin are our Brangelina, and Selena Gomez is our Jennifer Anniston. On multiple levels.
I just know that Justin Bieber is going to pull a Ross and say Selena during the vows.
— Tony Posnanski (@tonyposnanski) July 8, 2018
We throw our support behind her because the strong, single, wronged ex coming out on top is a much more helpful narrative for us. It’s the one we want to believe for our own sakes.
Selena is officially free! No more sudden throwbacks from her crazy ex! No more inspired songs about her! No more stans attacking her whenever she's seen with him! No more Hailey shading Selena! No more f boy! She deserves better ugh so happy my bby gon get what she deserves!
— sara (fan account) (@Selenaxririi) July 8, 2018
A core part of celebrity culture is the emotional investment we make in these glorified strangers, whether we intend to or not, and the victim narrative intensifies that empathy. That’s why our collective reaction is to console Selena Gomez like she’s our own friend and come to her defence so fiercely.
How PISSED is Selena Gomez right now? She did all the work domesticating Bieber. Put up with all his shit. And then Haley Baldwin just swoops right in for the ring and cashes in on all that hard work
— KFC (@KFCBarstool) July 8, 2018
And so, in defiant celebration of the ostensibly scorned member of the love triangle at hand, the ‘SelenaIsFreeParty’ hashtag was born.
“Selena is probably sitting in her room crying rn”#SelenaIsFreeParty pic.twitter.com/PpR5Xu55cO
— claudia (@fexishx) July 8, 2018
It’s the classic ‘You’re better off without him’ line that you tell your mate, or yourself to feel better. And if we believe it’s true for Selena, it can be true for us! So we really need it to be true for her.
The only toxic thing that will be in Selena’s life from now on is Toxic by Britney Spears? #SelenaIsFreeParty pic.twitter.com/UsJlC2RkXb
— L (@graceonsel) July 8, 2018
As is our tendency, we lean into supporting the ‘victim’, and find catharsis in relating to their experience. Selena Gomez is allowed to feel both happy and sad, and anything else she wants to because that’s the spectrum we want to be allowed to feel ourselves when we are hurt.
#SelenaIsFreeParty i'm haply but i hope selena won't be heartbroken over this she loved that man for 8 years it ain't easy
— chris(fan) (@cravegomezck) July 8, 2018
While the sting is still hot, being cast by the public as the victim in a love triangle gains you ultimate innocence status. No one is idealised more than a lover scorned.
Selena with the only person on the Earth who deserves Selena
#SelenaIsFreeParty pic.twitter.com/gAtlX82zhI
— ece (@selogies) July 8, 2018
What’s interesting is that our favour falls with the current ‘victim’ and can be shifted accordingly if the narrative changes. It wasn’t long ago that Bella Hadid had our sympathy when Selena Gomez and The Weeknd initially got together, or that it went to The Weeknd after Selena and Justin reunited.
Basically, celebrity alliances are a fickle thing, but rooting for whoever is left single is forever – because being independent and thriving is the narrative we all need a bit more of in our lives.